CalDescent 13eff43b87 Fixed synchronizer issues which caused large re-orgs
Peers without a recent block are removed at the start of the sync process, however, due to the time lag involved in fetching block summaries and comparing the list of peers, some of these could subsequently drop back to a non-recent block and still be chosen as the next peer to sync with. The end result being that nodes could unnecessarily orphan as many as 20 blocks due to syncing with a peer that doesn't have a recent block (but has a couple of high weight blocks after the common block).

This commit adds some additional filtering to avoid this situation.

1) Peers without a recent block are removed as candidates in comparePeers(), allowing for alternate peers to be chosen.
2) After comparePeers() completes, the list is filtered a second time to make sure that all are still recent.
3) Finally, the peer's state is checked one last time in syncToPeerChain(), just before any orphaning takes place.

Whilst just one of the above would probably have been sufficient, the consequences of this bug are so severe that it makes sense to be very thorough.

The only exception to the above is when the node is in "recovery mode", in which case peers without recent blocks are allowed to be included. Items 1 and 3 above do not apply in recovery mode. Item 2 does apply, since the entire comparePeers() functionality is already skipped in a recovery situation due to our chain being out of date.
2022-03-14 21:47:37 +00:00
..